There seem to be some mysteries about frogs in their breeding colonies this year and it started when the frogs should have been moving. They were heading out from their winter quarters, under stones and in holes in the ground, towards their traditional breeding sites. These sites vary considerably from loch and lochans to drainage ditches and garden ponds. The type of breeding sites can have problems particularly where the frogs lay their spawn in shallow water that may dry up. This often seems to happen but this is compensated for by the sheer number of places they choose. One mystery is that records suggest that frogs and toads are now choosing the same breeding sites where formally they seemed to choose different sites. Nobody seems to know why this trend is happening.
The main mystery this year was just when the frogs started moving and why, in some colonies, the numbers were so low. Frogs will hibernate in a wide variety of places and if the winter weather is mild they may just stay in the water. They can take in enough oxygen through their skin to keep them alive in the torpid state of hibernation. However, this is fraught with problems as if the water ices over for any length of time there is just not enough oxygen in the water and many will die under the ice. Unlike toads, that will mostly hibernate in one area, frogs tend to widely disperse from the breeding site. Then when the weather warms up in the spring they move out to the water. This just does not seem to have happened this year as very few frogs were on the move at one time. What prompts the initial move is a rise in temperature and rain and most frogs will move in a day or two days. Perhaps this year the mild weather lasted for several days so we did not see so many as it was spread over several days.
However this does not explain why the number of frogs at some breeding sites were so low and, more significantly, the number of clumps of spawn were well down at a number of sites, including some garden ponds. What makes this easier to assess is that one female will lay just one clump of spawn. So if you look at these early enough, before they grow and start to join together, one clump will mean there is one female. An idea of the numbers in a colony can then be compared from one year to the next. There is no chance of mixing this up with toads spawn as their habits are quite different. Toads lay their eggs in long strings that they wind round submerged aquatic plants. If the breeding site has deep water, which with toads is often the case, then the spawn is difficult to see. Indeed it is often the case of just not knowing a site has been used by breeding toads. Once the frogs’ spawn has hatched there are many predators that take their toll. This may be fish even as small as sticklebacks, to dragonfly larvae and the losses may seem significant. Even when the tadpoles have left the water in what may seem countless numbers to us then the predators are there waiting, especially birds. However, so many eggs are laid that even if a very small proportion are successful then it is enough to keep the overall frog numbers constant.